Which gfx card



New Member
Hello all!

I have a Celeron 533, 256MB and i currently use a Guillemot Maxi Gamer Phoenix 2 16Mb.

Im getting very good fps under Quake even at medium-high quality.

I was thinking for an upgrade though since id love to play RTCW (just bought it, havent tried it yet to see how it performs).

At the beginning i was thinking of a Kyro II but i listen to every one here saying that it wont perform well in a cpu under 1Ghz (amazed since my TNT based cards is running great, but i guess it has to do with the T&L thing)

My question is, should i go for:
1. Hercules Prophet 4500, Kyro 2, 64 MB Sdram
2. Hercules Prophet II, GeForce2 MX400, 32 MB Sdram
3. ATI Radeon 7200, 64 MB Sdram

Im a bit worried about ATI and drivers issues. :-\

I wouldnt like to spend more than that price range.



New Member
I would suggest GF3 TI 200 or any of the TI line. They are the newest video cards from Nvidia. I beleive Nvidia is planning to introduce a new card in January, so probably a price drop in the TI's at that time.

Technology increases at a parabolic curve upward.


Well Cue, I'm trying to sell my S3 Savage2000 card for a GeForce2 Titanium. Much cheaper than the GF3, yet performs almost up there from what I've heard. For $145 shipped I can get it with 64MB DDR 4ns memory which supposedly clocks to about 500MHz DDR.

That news about a new nVidia chip...that's awesome..I was planning on waiting til after Christmas to get my new card anyways! That means my GF2 Ti will be even cheaper!! Yay!!!!

MSI K7T Turbo-R w/ voltage mod ;) (2,15v)
dead duron...XP soon?
256MB Corsair PC150 CL2
S3 Savage2000 64MB AGP4x
Buslink 12x/40x DVD
Sony 12x/8x/32x CDRW
Water-cooled 118w Peltier


New Member
I would snuff the MX.
The other 2 cards will probably offer similar performance on your system. The Radeon has T&L, which is very handy when running q3, which uses T&L quite a bit. My H4500 tends to slow down in q3 occasionally, since it makes my 1gig athlon do all the T&L work.
There are Geforce2 gts and pros out there right now that are selling cheap. Hardest part my be finding one that is still in stock. Check pricewatch.com.

Never argue with an idiot. They drag you down to their level, then beat you with experience.


New Member
Looking at your system, I'd go for a faster CPU and a cheaper VGA card.

I have a 64MB GeForce2 MX400 which I did have with a K6-2 500 and 192MB PC133 RAM. I then upgraded mobo (MSI K7T Turbo2), CPU (Duron 900), and RAM (384MB until 128MB of it crapped out on me
). I've experienced a massive increase in gameplay speed; it was definitely worth it, and I've got a faster all-round system as well.

I reckon a Celly 733 or above, 512MB, and either no. 2 in your list or a GF3 Ti200 as evetsrim suggested. I'm not entirely sure about ATI cards, cos I've never had one. Also, depending on your present mobo, you could go for a new one if you're thinking of a 1GHz+ CPU.

As money appears to be a limiting factor, the ProphetII could be the best choice. I'd seriously consider a CPU/RAM upgrade as well, though.

good luck, mate !

Spitfire [email protected]
256MB PC 133
Toshi 16x DVD
SB Live! 1024
64MB GF2 MX400
Uni life... so entertaining...

[This message has been edited by RecklessLeper (edited 12-09-2001).]