If you can get better performance for less money and it's the same tube, then get the Samsung. I'd check if they have convergence adjustment as well, on a large screen it is very useful as most aren't perfect when they ship or can become misconverged with time.
I don't know what prices you are looking at but the Iiyama VM Pro 454 is an excellent 19" screen and will do 1600x1200@110Hz for you. It's not that expensive these days, only £260 in the UK, but relatively speaking I don't know how much you're looking to drop on the screens you've listed.
If you've got your money for nothing, who cares if the chicks are free!