I say neither. If noise is a problem go with the Millennium Glaciator. You can get it for 48 shipped from pcnut.com. If noise is not a problem get the ThermalRight SK-6, it can be had for arround 35 dollars. This heatsink will out perform any other heatsink you can find for upto 80 dollars.
------------------
T-Bird 800@968
Abit KT7
512 crucial pc133 cas 2
Geforce 2 GTS
30 gig Maxtor
SB Live Value
win 98
16x Pioneer DVD
8x4x32 burner
19 inch Sony
T-Bird 800@940
Epox 8KHA
512 crucial pc2100
Geforce 2 Pro
30 gig Maxtor
SB Live Value
win 98
16x Slot Pioneer DVD
8x4x32
19 inch Sony
Bookmarks